Table of Contents
You’re standing in the produce aisle, heart sinking as you eye the fries you really want, only to grab the bag of kale instead. You may think, “Why do I always choose kale?”
Maybe you’ve felt that twinge of judgment elsewhere, too. Such as when a well-meaning friend yells out, “YOU CAN’T HAVE THAT!!”. Or, mid-scroll on Instagram, seeing yet another “clean plate” post and wondering if you’ll ever get it right.
I’ve heard every “you can’t have that” story out there. But I’m not the food police. Dietitians don’t hand out tickets for cookies, and you don’t need to play badge-waver in your own kitchen.
Real talk: If I wanted a lecture, I’d go back to my college nutrition class. So let’s ditch the finger-wagging right now.
The “Food Police” Myth: Where It Comes From
Headlines that blare “Fat Is the Enemy” and influencers preaching “clean vs. dirty” really muck up how we see pizza and salad alike. Soon, every snack feels like a moral test.
That kind of black-and-white logic didn’t just pop up overnight. Over the decades, diet culture taught us that self-control equals virtue…
No wonder families juggling work, school runs, and mental health support end up feeling like they need permission to eat the foods they love.
Diet-Culture Roots
Our culture has long equated self-control with virtue, teaching us that willpower alone determines our worth.
In fact, 58.6% of teenage girls and 28.2% of teenage boys report actively dieting, often before they’ve even learned true hunger and fullness cues.
Layer on the nonstop barrage of “ideal body” images, every billboard, magazine cover, and Instagram post whispering that thin equals success, and suddenly, every bite feels like a test of your character.
Over time, those black-and-white rules seep into our own thinking: one cookie becomes proof you’ve “failed,” so you might as well finish the whole batch. That cycle of restraint and binge doesn’t just wreck habits; it erodes trust in yourself.
Misunderstanding of the Dietitian Role
I hear it all the time in my first sessions: clients confess they were scared to meet a “calorie cop.”
They expect judgment before they even step through the door. A single scary story can paint us all as food cops. Let’s clear that up: We’re on your team, not the judge’s bench. We’re here to partner with you on realistic, guilt-free changes. You deserve guidance, not a citation for every slice of pizza.
(Did we kill this metaphor yet?)
Dietitian’s Tip:
Remember: Food has no moral value. It simply provides nutrients, community, and pleasure.
The Harm of Food Policing
Any time someone claims to know ALL the answers or refuses to consider nuance and individuality, take their information and “knowledge” with a grain of salt.
Psychological Toll
That pattern slowly erodes your self-trust. One slip feels like a knockout punch, so why lace up again? Turns out, emotional eating spikes in people who see food “mistakes” as total defeats.
Research shows that 22.4% of children and adolescents display signs of disordered eating on the SCOFF screening tool, a prevalence that underscores how common these guilt-driven patterns have become.
Over time, that pattern chips away at your trust in yourself: if you believe one slip means total failure, why try next time? Research shows all-or-nothing thinking is linked to higher rates of emotional eating and lower self-efficacy. So, instead of feeling empowered, you end up doubting your ability to make balanced choices at all.
Relationship with Food
Policing turns meals into a chore.
Imagine dreading Taco Tuesday because you know you “shouldn’t” have the shells or tensing every time the ice cream carton comes out of the freezer.
That stress actually raises cortisol, which can trigger cravings or, later, lead you to skip meals entirely to “make up” for a treat. Over time, spontaneity vanishes.
No more impromptu pizza nights or cozy popcorn-and-movie rituals because the fear of stepping “over the line” becomes too heavy a price for a moment of joy.
Impact on Mental Health
Rigid rules aren’t just stressful. They can be dangerous.
Among youth with BMI over 26, one quarter report episodes of loss-of-control (binge) eating, linking restrictive environments directly to harmful eating behaviors. Constant vigilance around food breeds anxiety; mealtimes become a tightrope walk instead of a chance to refuel and reconnect.
And when children hear “You can’t have that,” they absorb moral judgments about food and themselves.
That shame-based messaging in childhood and adolescence often takes years to undo, keeping families stuck in cycles of guilt and secrecy.
Dietitian’s Tip:
Use neutral language at home: “Let’s try adding these strawberries with your snack.”
Foundations of a Health-Promoting, “No Food Police” Approach
Food isn’t a math problem. It’s fuel, culture, and pure joy. When you ditch perfectionism and embrace flexibility, you’ll actually stick with healthy habits. Forget “all or nothing.” Let’s roll with life’s curveballs and still feel amazing about our plates.
Core Principles
Ask, “What works for you?”
Every family has its own rhythms. Maybe you’re up before dawn for shift work, or homework runs late into the evening. I start by understanding your real-life schedule, budget, and cultural foods.
Build on strengths
If you already pour a glass of water before breakfast, we celebrate that, then layer on a serving of fruit. Small wins lead to big changes.
Collaboration over judgment
Think of our sessions as teamwork. You know yourself and your day-to-day best; I bring the science and strategies. Together, we craft a plan that fits your life, not some poster board ideal.
Diverse Representation
Healthy eating doesn’t look the same for every plate.
Maybe your favorite comfort food is plantains fried in olive oil, a steaming chapati, or tamales wrapped in corn husks. We honor those traditions, finding ways to boost nutrients without tossing out the recipes that make your family feel at home.
Centering on Behavior, Not Morality
Rather than banning foods, we focus on adding health-promoting habits. Start pairing your snack with chopped veggies or whole-grain crackers alongside the cheese or chips. Tiny tweaks build momentum without triggering the “forbidden food” effect that leads to overindulging.
Key Principles from Intuitive Eating & The Mindful Eating Workbook
- Reject the Diet Mentality: Drop moral labels—no more “bad” foods—so you can make choices from a place of curiosity, not shame.
- Honor Your Hunger & Fullness: Try gentle awareness exercises to check in with your body’s signals so you learn when to start and stop eating.
- Psychosocial Considerations: Stress, emotions, and social pressures all influence what and how we eat. Develop coping strategies, such as mindful breathing or partner check-ins, to stay grounded when life gets hectic.
With these foundations, you gain permission to enjoy a balanced diet that fits your family, your culture, and your schedule without ever needing a food-cop badge.
How to Drop the Food-Cop Habit Yourself: Practical Strategies for Families and Individuals
Reframe Language
Words carry weight.
Instead of saying, “You shouldn’t have that,” try, “You might notice how this snack makes you feel,” or “Consider trying a few carrot sticks alongside those chips.”
When we drop “good/bad” or “allowed/disallowed” labels, food stops feeling like a moral test, and eating becomes a chance to learn what works for your body.
Practical Strategies
Check in with your body.
Before you reach for something, pause and ask, “Am I really hungry, or just thirsty, tired, or stressed?” Those three seconds of mindfulness can steer you toward water, a quick stretch, or a few deep breaths instead of mindless snacking.
Schedule your treats.
Turn indulgences into rituals: cookie Mondays, ice-cream Sundays, or pizza Fridays. When you know a sweet moment is coming, you’re less likely to feel like you’ve “blown it” if you enjoy something earlier in the week.
You’ll enjoy it more and be less likely to feel deprived when that stale donut shows up in the break room.
However, also note that you are totally allowed to enjoy treats outside of your “schedule.”
Portion food
If you love ice cream, dish out one serving in a pretty dish with a fun topping. Savor each spoonful without rushing. Mindful portioning builds trust in your appetite cues, so you don’t feel deprived or compelled to overeat later.
How do you feel when you eat it? Not the food noise, but how does your body feel?
Body Image Boosters
Shift praise from appearance to effort. Instead of “Good job, looking slim,” try “I love how you included those extra veggies today.” Focusing on strengths, like cooking skills or trying a new food, reinforces confidence without tying it to your body shape.
Accountability Without Guilt
Share your journey. Tell a friend, partner, or me when something feels hard. Talking it out keeps you accountable, and when you celebrate small victories (“You added an extra serving of greens this week!”), it feels genuine, not forced.
By weaving these strategies into your routine, you’ll loosen the grip of the “food police” and build a kinder, more sustainable relationship with eating, one choice at a time.
Real talk: My own snack “cheat?” Movie theatre popcorn with dark chocolate chips while binge-watching 2 Broke Girls.
What Dietitans Actually Do
Empathy-Driven Counseling
I start by listening—really listening—to your life. What does your morning routine look like? Which cultural dishes bring your family together? By understanding your schedule, budget, and favorite foods (whether that’s plantain mofongo or veggie-packed stir-fries), I can tailor guidance that fits seamlessly into your world; no guilt, no judgment.
Behavioral Goals Over Weight Goals
We focus on steps you can actually achieve. Maybe we begin with drinking a full glass of water before breakfast, or adding one extra color to lunch with a handful of bell peppers. These small, concrete habits boost confidence and momentum far more than chasing a number on the scale ever could.
Collaborative Problem-Solving
You know your plate best, and I bring the nutrition expertise. Together, we co-create meal plans that honor your tastes, wallet, and health needs. Struggling with after-school snack battles? We brainstorm kid-approved combos. Feeling stressed midday? We build in mini mindful-eating breaks.
This teamwork approach ensures lasting change because you’re not doing it alone.
Moments of “A-ha”
Marisol’s Midweek Treat-Day
Marisol is a single mom working evening shifts at a childcare center. Between drop-offs, pickups, and lesson planning, she found herself grabbing drive-thru fries more nights than she’d like.
Together, we built in a “Wednesday Treat Day,” a pre-planned scoop of ice cream or a small bag of chips, so she could look forward to a moment of fun without derailing the rest of her week. Now, she reports fewer impulse runs and more calm evenings at home with her kids.
Devon’s Budget-Friendly Veggie Win
Devon, a junior majoring in engineering, lived on ramen and takeout until we added in frozen mixed vegetables and pantry spices. He learned that a bag of broccoli, cauliflower, and carrots, tossed with olive oil and paprika, beats the cost of even the cheapest pizza slice.
By cooking once for the week and portioning into reusable containers, he saved money and gained extra study fuel. His grades and energy both saw an uptick.
Mrs. Nguyen’s Plant-Boosted Classics
Retired librarian Mrs. Nguyen missed her family’s traditional banh xeo (Vietnamese pancakes) but worried about the richness of the filling. We kept her favorite recipe intact and simply added mashed tofu and extra mung beans alongside the pork, boosting plant protein without sacrificing flavor.
Now, her Sunday gatherings feel just as celebratory; she notices less afternoon fatigue, and she even found that without the pork, she can feed her vegetarian neighbors at the next block party.
Each of these stories shows how a “no food police” approach (flexible, personalized, and culture-forward) can fit into real lives and bring lasting change.
Dietitian’s Tip:
Your body remembers kindness; allow one choice this week that feels joyful, not judged
Wrapping Up
Let’s remember: policing food never built healthy habits. Empathy and flexibility do. When you swap rules for curiosity, you create space to discover what truly nourishes your body and your soul.
Take a moment to reflect: What’s one rigid food rule you’d like to soften or drop this week? Jot it down, share it with someone you trust, or leave a comment below to hold yourself accountable.
If you want to dive deeper, check out “Intuitive Eating” by Evelyn Tribole and Elyse Resch for a guide to dropping diet mentalities and “The Mindful Eating Workbook” by Vincci Tsui for practical exercises in gentle awareness.
You’ve got permission to enjoy food, and I’ve got your back every step of the way. Let’s choose compassion over control, one bite at a time.
Jennifer Hanes MS, RDN, LD is a registered dietitian, mom, wife, and vegetarian in North Texas. She has dedicated Dietitian Jenn to be a source of information, ideas, and inspiration for people like her, vegetarians that live with people with different dietary beliefs and/or needs in a multivore household.